Outdoor cooking buying guide

Grills, Smokers & Griddles: How to Choose

Charcoal flavor, gas convenience or griddle versatility, and how to set any of them up at home, at the campsite, on the RV bumper or on the boat rail.

44 in-stock picks Updated November 16, 2026 30-day returns · Secure checkout
Shop the picks
GRAVITY SERIES 600 DIGITAL CHARCOAL GRILL + SMOKERHEX OGATAN CHARCOAL 10LB BOXKamado Joe Classic Joe III Charcoal Grill With Hyperbolic Insert Heat Deflector And ToolsOVAL XLARGE CHARCOAL ALLINONE (HEAVYDUTY STAND SIDE SHELVES ASH TOOL & GRATE LIFTER)
Smokers and charcoal grills comparedGas grills and flat top griddlesGrilling on the road: RV, boat and tailgate setupsSafety, covers and toolsShop the picks ↓

Picking an outdoor cooker starts with one question: what do you cook most, and where? Low and slow brisket and ribs point you toward a smoker. Weeknight burgers and chicken favor a gas grill that lights in seconds. Breakfast for a campsite full of people is a griddle's job. And if the cooker travels in an RV, on a boat or to a tailgate, how it mounts and connects to propane matters as much as how it cooks.

This guide compares charcoal, gravity-fed, offset, drum and electric smokers, gas grills and flat top griddles, then covers RV, boat and tailgate setups and safety, covers and tools. Brands we stock include Masterbuilt (Gravity Series and electric smokers), Oklahoma Joe's, Char-Broil, Blackstone, Flame King, Phoenix Grills and Kamado Joe accessories, plus mounting and propane parts from Camco, Fleming Sales, MORryde, Marshall Excelsior and MB Sturgis.

Smokers and charcoal grills compared

TypeHow it worksStrengthsTrade-offs
Gravity-fed charcoalA tall hopper feeds charcoal down into a firebox; a digital controller and fan hold the set temperatureCharcoal flavor with set-and-forget control; can grill hot or smoke lowNeeds electric power for the fan and controller; more parts
Offset smokerFire burns in a side firebox; heat and smoke draw across the main chamberClassic barbecue flavor, big capacity, often doubles as a grillNeeds fire tending and practice to hold steady temperatures
Drum smokerCharcoal basket at the bottom of an upright drum, food hangs or sits aboveEfficient, compact, holds temperature well once setSmaller footprint means less flat cooking space
Electric smokerHeating element warms a wood chip tray in an insulated boxEasiest to use, very steady temperatureMilder smoke flavor; needs an outlet
Tabletop charcoalSmall kettle or box grillPortable for tailgates and campingLimited cooking area

The Masterbuilt Gravity Series 600 and XT are the gravity-fed option: fill the hopper, set the temperature on the digital panel, and the fan does the rest. Oklahoma Joe's covers the traditional side: the Highland offset smoker, the Bronco drum smoker, the Marshal centerbox smoker, the Canyon combo (charcoal and gas in one) and the Rambler tabletop grill. The Masterbuilt 30 inch analog electric smoker is the simplest route to smoked food. Kamado-style owners can add capacity with accessories like the Kamado Joe Classic Joe grill expander.

A good rule: if you enjoy tending a fire, an offset or drum is rewarding. If you want results without babysitting, a gravity-fed or electric unit makes long cooks much easier.

Gas grills and flat top griddles

Gas grills win on convenience: push-button ignition, quick heat-up and easy temperature control. The main specs to compare are the number of burners (more burners give you separate hot and cool zones), cooking area, side burners for sauces and sides, and whether the grill runs on propane (LP) or natural gas (NG). Most grills are built for one fuel; converting usually requires a manufacturer-approved kit, so buy the version that matches your setup. We carry Char-Broil Performance Series 4 and 5 burner grills, the Char-Broil Pro Series grill and griddle combo, the Phoenix stainless grill on a column base and the Modern Home Products JNR4 natural gas grill head.

Flat top griddles are a solid steel cooking surface over burners. They handle food that falls through grates: eggs, pancakes, smash burgers, fried rice, chopped vegetables. They are hugely popular for camping and tailgating because one surface feeds a crowd. The Blackstone 22 inch Omnivore and 28 inch Original Omnivore, the Blackstone camping griddle, the Char-Broil 28 inch 2 burner griddle and the Flame King RV propane flat top griddle cover sizes from tabletop to full cart.

NeedGood fit
Weeknight grilling, quick start3 to 5 burner gas grill
Breakfast, camp cooking, crowdsFlat top griddle, 22 to 36 inch
Both on one cartGrill and griddle combo
RV or tailgate travelTabletop griddle or portable grill with a low-pressure propane hookup

New griddle tops need to be seasoned with thin coats of oil heated until they darken, which builds a non-stick, rust-resistant surface. Follow the maker's instructions and keep the top oiled and covered between uses.

Grilling on the road: RV, boat and tailgate setups

RV propane hookups: many RVs have a low-pressure propane quick-connect port on the side. A portable grill with its own regulator usually cannot plug straight into it; you need the correct adapter or conversion kit for your specific grill. Examples include the Marshall Excelsior portable grill conversion kits (including one for the Coleman RoadTrip), the AP Products and MB Sturgis kits for Weber Q grills, and the MB Sturgis quick-connect inlet adapter for Blackstone griddles. Match the kit to your grill model and your RV's connection, and leak test every new connection with soapy water before lighting.

Bumper and slide-out mounts: a bumper arm like the Fleming Sales grill arm table for Weber Q or the Fleming bumper arm griddle table holds a cooker off the ground on the RV's rear bumper. MORryde griddle slides and slide-out trays mount into an outdoor kitchen compartment so the griddle pulls out ready to cook. Check your bumper's weight rating and mounting style first; many RV bumpers are not designed for heavy loads.

Boat rail mounts: Camco Stow N Go grill mounts clamp to round boat rails (check the listed rail sizes, such as 7/8 inch and 1.25 inch) so a compatible grill hangs outboard, away from the deck. Never leave a grill unattended on a boat, and keep it clear of fuel vapors and canvas.

Hauling a cooker to a campsite? Pair it with the right cooler, and if you are shading an outdoor kitchen, see our RV awnings guide.

Safety, covers and tools

  • Outdoors only. Charcoal, propane and wood produce carbon monoxide. Never use a grill, smoker or griddle inside a garage, tent, RV or enclosed cabin, even with a door open.
  • Keep clearance. Follow the maker's minimum distances from walls, railings, vinyl siding and awnings. Do not cook directly under an RV awning.
  • Check propane connections every season and whenever you swap a tank: brush soapy water on the connection and look for bubbles.
  • Cook to temperature. Use a food thermometer. Per USDA guidance, poultry should reach 165 F, ground meats 160 F, and whole cuts of beef, pork, lamb and veal 145 F with a 3 minute rest. Check current USDA guidance for other foods.
  • Let ashes cool fully, or douse them, before disposal in a metal container.

A fitted cover protects against rain, UV and rust. Match the cover to your exact model, such as the Primo grill covers, the Hitchfire Forge 15 cover or the GHP covers for barrel charcoal grills and compact smokers. Camco's Kuuma tote cover protects a portable grill in storage. For griddles, Blackstone wind guards keep burners lit in a breeze, and the Blackstone griddle gloves, tool kit and carry bag round out the kit.

In-stock grills, smokers, griddles and accessories

Every product below is in stock now. Prices update daily.

Frequently asked questions

Is a gravity-fed charcoal smoker hard to use?+
No. That is the point of the design. You load the hopper, set a temperature on the controller and the fan regulates the fire. It does need a power outlet, and you still need to clean out ash and refill charcoal on long cooks.
Can I convert a propane grill to natural gas?+
Only if the manufacturer offers an approved conversion kit for that model. Orifices, valves and regulators differ between fuels, so do not improvise. If you have a natural gas line, buying an NG-specific grill is usually simplest.
Can I hook my portable grill to my RV's propane?+
Often, with the right adapter. Many RVs have a low-pressure quick-connect port, and kits exist for popular grills and griddles like Weber Q, Coleman RoadTrip and Blackstone. Match the kit to your grill and RV, and leak test before use.
Griddle or grill for camping?+
A griddle is more versatile for camp meals because it cooks eggs, pancakes and chopped food as well as burgers. A grill gives char marks and suits steaks and chicken. Many campers bring a tabletop griddle and use the campfire for grilling.
Do I need to season a new griddle?+
Yes. Steel griddle tops are seasoned by heating thin layers of cooking oil until they darken, which builds a non-stick, rust-resistant surface. Re-oil lightly after each cook and keep the griddle covered.

Further reading

More buying guides

Find the perfect parts for your ride
Shop top brands at unbeatable prices.